Writer : M. Lilla and C. Bishop Barry
This is an essay written by the two American geographers M. Lilla and C. Bishop Barry present an exploration of the Karnali region which they did on foot for 15 adventurous months. After Christmas the two authors start their trip to know how Karnali is economically linked with Nepalgunj. Their fellow travelers bring medicinal herbs, hashish hand-knit sweaters and blankets in their baskets ~ to sell them in Nepalgunj.
During their trip on foot, the two geographers see and learn many things about the life and culture of the people of Karnali region. On their way, a chhetri woman of 30 asks them whether they are going to Nepalgunj. According to her, her husband left her 15 years ago to find job in the plains the woman requests the authors to send him back if they find him. In a forest at 9,000 feet, they see some people processing Silajit sell it in Nepalgunj. Instead of processing it in their homes, they do it on the way because they have made a hurried trip to avoid a bad start. The people of the Karnali regions are superstitious as they believe that a bad star may have evil influence on them.
They continue their journey, and notice some women cutting the branches of the ‘Sal’ trees to feed their goats. Almost all the trees have become bare. This shows that the people of Karnali zone are not aware of the possible environmental damage. They are ignorant about landslides, soil erosion, droughts etc. in the future. When the authors reach terai, they sit beside a campfire and listen to the night sounds of jackals, bats, mules and bullock carts. They walk on the paved streets and see the vehicles. Their fellow travelers or the people of Karnali region buy collon clothes, spice, jewelry, iron ware, aluminum and sweets to sell them in Karnali. The authors complete their exploration in Jumla.
While they got back to the Terai region, the two American geographers learn a lot about the geographical condition and the life of people of the Karnali region. The authors observe all the seasons and the people who have been living in harmony with nature. They have been living very difficult life. As their cultivation can not support them, they have to involve them in trade. Some people go’to the plains in search of job. Thus, the people of Karnali zone are uneducated, conservative and they earn their living by the various traditional works.
1. Give a short account of life of Karnali zone people.
Two American geographers have depicted (painted) and described
the state and lifestyle of Karnali zone. The life of Karnali zone people is
extremely hard because Karnali zone is a remote, not well connected
with other parts of the country by road and economically backward.
Because of lack of education they are very superstitious and believe that
a bad star may have evil influence on them and try to avoid it. They are
lacking the awareness about the need of preservation of nature. Due to
lack of this aspect they indiscriminately chopped down the trees there by
speeding of the deforestation putting their own life’s in great risk
because the entire slopes became bare and prone (possible) of landslide
and soil erosion.
Although the people of this region are living in harmony with
nature in very difficult location with very bad weather, they are not
ready to leave their place. The writer found that a hill place is very
optimistic and cheerful despite hardship in life with low agricultural
production. The writers felt the need of the hill people to farm with other
activities to live with satisfactory earning. Many of them are involved in
business. They carry their local products including Silajit to sell in
Nepalgunj whenever they go down to the Terai. When they return home
they bring necessary goods like aluminum and iron wares, cotton
clothes, jewelry items and spices to sell in their locality to earn a living.
2. What does skeletal looking SAL trees indicate about the exploitation of nature? What does the reply “What we can do? The animals must eat today” signify?
Ans: The scene they are indifferently cutting down the trees and they are not worried about the jungle and their own future. They are doing just to solve their current problem. They are not conscious about the future. They are not realizing their mistakes may have disastrous consequences.
3. In the description of Karnali, written in 1971,….
ANS: Gradually, there are some changes in the grip of twenty five years in Karnali. There were no post offices, no high schools and no health post and a health clinic at the center of the villages. Development pace is very slow. The geogrohical structure is responsible for the development because in hilly areas it is difficult to apply the developmental projects. So, Karnali is still underdevelopment.
In the past, people were uneducated but now they are educated. Only few people are involved in education and most of the people, in Karnali, are involved in agriculture. They are still following porter job. There are no faculities. People do not go to clinic in a general case which shows they are not conscious about health and they don’t believe in science but educated people use clinic well. In conclusion, the people in Karnali are being developed although they are not developing as the writer thinks. But they have understood the benefit of education and development.
Have a question? Ask us in our discussion forum.